Published: 04-Nov-2025 (08:36); Viewed: 129; Difficulty: 1 out of 10
Rating: N/A
k
This year's Steel City Beer Festival in Kelham Island was my return to one of the UK's most characterful beer gatherings. Number 49 in the long-running Sheffield tradition, it once again brought together a wide range of ales - from strong IPAs to light bitters - but my personal goal was clear: find the best mild.
About Mild
Mild ales are an old British classic, known for their soft maltiness, low bitterness, and gentle strength. They're often underrated and, sadly, underrepresented at many festivals. So I decided to focus on every mild available this year, rate them honestly, and see if any could stand out.
Tested Milds
Sun Goes Down (3.3% ABV, Thornbridge) - 4.5/10 A pleasant dark mild with a light aroma but too watery. The promised richness never appeared. Disappointing for such a respected brewery.
Tom's Mild (3.4% ABV, Stancill) - 5.5/10 Smoother and fruitier, but still missing depth. A nice everyday pint but far from memorable.
XL Mild (4.0% ABV, Burton Bridge) - 6.5/10 The best of the lineup. A fuller body with caramel and toffee tones, yet still a little thin compared to classic Midlands milds.
Dark Horse Mild (3.7% ABV, Uttoxeter) - 5.0/10 Balanced sweetness and mild fruitiness, but over-carbonated and lacking in aroma.
Conclusion about Milds
After trying all four, it was clear that this year wasn't a strong one for milds. Each beer had pleasant qualities, but none achieved that deep, creamy malt character that defines a truly great mild. Still, festivals like this keep these traditional styles alive, and it's always a pleasure to support real ale culture.
Sun Goes Down - 4.5/10 Tom's Mild - 5.5/10 XL Mild - 6.5/10 Dark Horse Mild - 5.0/10
Even if the milds didn't impress, the Steel City Beer Festival remains an unmissable event for beer lovers. Every visit brings new discoveries — and sometimes, even disappointment can be part of the adventure.